Sign in Subscribe
2 min read

The Hunt for a Real Slush Puppie: A New Jersey Nostalgia Story

Once a childhood classic across New Jersey, the Slush Puppie is vanishing fast. Now locals are on Reddit, swapping leads and chasing the last icy relics of the 90s. The Garden State Gazette joins the hunt.

By The Garden State Gazette Staff

A Slushy Memory

For many New Jerseyans, the Slush Puppie once signalled a childhood treat: that bracing chill, sugar-rush sweetness, and the simple joy of pressing the lever on a frozen beverage machine. The brand, created in 1970, was beloved for its crushed-ice texture in syrup, and its mascot, “Chilly” the puppy in a knit cap.

But fast forward to today and the hunt is on: where can you still grab a real Slush Puppie in the Garden State?

The Reddit Trail: “Still Alive?”

On the subreddit r/newjersey, users have been on the case:

“They can be found in locations that want frozen drinks but don’t want a more expensive and higher-maintenance ICEE machine.”
“There’s a Exxon in Mt. Arlington … across the street from the Quick Check that sells Slush Puppies.”
“What’s somebody gotta do to get a Slush Puppie in north NJ?! I’ve searched high and low…”

One Redditor recalls:

“My middle school cafeteria had one of these in the late 80s! … I remember begging my mom to get me one every damn time we went to the Bradlees in Clark.”

Why the Disappearance?

Several factors seem to contribute to the rarity of the machine-dispensed Slush Puppie in New Jersey today:

  • Maintenance & cost: Slush machines require cleaning, upkeep, and syrup supply; several users noted stores switched to alternatives because of “higher-maintenance” systems.
  • Brand consolidation: The Slush Puppie brand, once independent, became part of larger food-&-beverage conglomerates.

Consumer switching: Many stores shifted to more visible or easier options like ICEE or other slushie brands. One user put it succinctly:

“Not looking for the freezer-section stuff… we want it in the cup, with the ice, and too many pumps of syrup and zero carbonation.”

So, Where Are the Machines Now?

If you’re determined to find one, here are some leads from the Reddit community (not guarantees):

  • A gas station in Mt. Arlington (north NJ) reportedly still had one.
  • Some convenience stores in Sussex County, 7-11s and independents, were mentioned.
  • One trampoline park in South Jersey claimed to still offer machine-Slush Puppies.

The Appeal: Nostalgia Meets Sweetness

There’s a deeper emotional pull here than just sugar and ice. Slush Puppie is tied to memories of summers, school cafeterias, roller rinks, corner stores—iconic New Jersey moments. One commenter put it:

“Slush puppy at a roller rink is peak 90s nostalgia.”

In a world of slick beverages and artisan trends, finding a classic Slush Puppie machine is like striking a time-capsule moment.

The GSG Call to Action

We challenge you, New Jersey readers:

  • Snap a photo if you find a working Slush Puppie machine in the state and tag us.
  • Let us know store, town, flavour availability.
  • Bonus: Did it cost the same as you remember? Is the taste still the same?

We’ll publish a “Last Stands of the Slush Puppie” map based on your findings. Let’s keep the memory — and the machine — alive.

*For more weird & wonderful New Jersey food hunts, keep it locked on The Garden State Gazette.